I'm an evangelical but not a fanatic. I guess I'm what you call a unicorn. I believe in God and I've read the Bible more than once, cover to cover. With that being said - I'm pro-choice. I don't think that my viewpoints or beliefs should have any bearing on what someone else does or does not do.
Free will. We've had it since Adam and Eve screwed up. (Which I'm still trying to wrap my head around). We can make whatever choices we want for ourselves. Others don't have to like it or even approve of it. It's not their concern.
People and whatever god they believe in will have a face to face when the time comes. Let the two of them work it out.